The consistency and friendliness of the service with wines over a wide price range makes Jimmy watson’s the Carlton Institution always worth returning to.

Fantastic service from Nigel, food and wine were outstanding. Highly recommend.

The Agnoloti was delicious, great flavors and just the right amount of cook time on all ingredients. Service was great, very attentive. All good, thank you,

A great place highly recommend for service and quality as well as atmosphere

Dine here frequently and never disappointed. Great food with good variety.

Lovely food at a reasonable price. We will be back. Thank you for asking.

Excellent dining as usual. Well looked after. Recommend to anyone who loves fine dining

A warm welcome, outstanding and discreet service, delicious food and wine. JW is simply the best.

We had a lovely meal in the courtyard in the shade.

Cheerful staff Good wine selection Atmosphere as it has been for fifty years- relaxed

First visit in 35 years and it was as good as ever

rushed, not relaxing as we should be in lovely courtyard

Courtyard pleasant as always. Waiter Nigel (sommelier??) off-hand and if he knows anything about wine seemed unwilling to share it. Steak so overdone it was sent back. Duck tepid and overcooked and probably should have been sent back. The four of us have experience of JW's dating back several decades, and it has varied over time. But this was bad. Shame.

Been a long 9 years since last vist family history going back to the 1960 s made to feel most welcome great food and even better wine

Everything fine at the restaurant. But food poisoning from the chicken Parmesan. Only thing it could have been.

Always good at Jimmy Watson’s, good wine, food and atmosphere.

Great food and service! And lovely to be out in the garden.

Very suitable for our catch up with interstate friends that we had not seen for two years. We could talk and hear each other! Great waiter. Thank you

We really enjoyed being able to eat outside in the courtyard.

Lovely food,nice wine and a pleasant atmosphere .Not rushed and we could hear each other talk .

Fabulous good as always and great service though a little slow getting us to table and taking drinks order. That’s unusual. iI’s a great place and we go for dinner every month.

Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Great food and ambience. Great place to meet up with friends and colleagues

Food wasn’t great but the staff were awesome, and the drinks were excellent. I love the atmosphere, it’s a great place to take family and friends.

Delicious food at reasonable prices. The side order of vegetables was just right for the meal.

no need to add what i marked yeah just a press the top button utan utan utan utan utan President okay me 23 yeah utan Carol you yeah is well shoes no steel dress yeah utan utan utan listen utan yeah yeah the barrister utan utan

Always enjoy coming to this special restaurant which has a unique atmosphere

Great food great wine shared experience with friends. A favourite place!

Made to feel special Good selection of wines excellent friendly service

Good food and wine and attentive staff . Great atmosphere.

Great food, great atmosphere. Would highly recommend for a good night out.

Tasty food, good service, excellent wine choice. A good place to meet with friends and not have to yell to hear over other customers

Always good food and drink with prompt service at Jimmy Watson’s. Yesterday was again a positive experience. Thank you Ian and Lois.

Celebrity lunch with work colleague. Nice atmosphere where you could hear each other speak! Pleasant service

Jimmy Watsons is a great venue. The food is good value for money with some good specials on offer. Wine list very good. Atmosphere fantastic.

Great food, great service in a relaxed atmosphere. Highly recommend.

Lunch with my son. Super food and service. Great atmosphere.

We hadn't been to Jimmy Watson's for a while but will definitely return after last night's dinner. The tuna salad was great and the panna cotta delicious. Service was a little erratic and noise level was high at times, but it is a neighbourhood gem.

Great service and good. Pleasant atmosphere making a celebration lunch very special

Fantastic food and service. All the staff are extremely friendly and polite.

Jimmy Watson's is an iconic and loved Melbourne destination. Thr service is attentive and friendly, the menu is interesting and the food is excellent and plentiful. The wine list is, of course, wonderful. It is always a pleasure to spend time here

Lovely Sunday afternoon, enjoying a family lunch with good service and a comfortable atmosphere

Jimmy Watson’s is an institution. Food excellent and great service but a highlight is the wines!

A very noisy table made it very hard to have a reasonable conversation

Jimmy Watsons is a Melbourne/Carlton institution. The mean age of the diners must be 70? I always meet old friends there. The ambiance and service is excellent with no frills. Just consistent service with, of course, some very good wines. Conversation is the name of the game. Us venerable folk have a wealth of information to share. Jimmy’s is the place to do that.

The food waiter was excellent. The coffee waiter spilt my coffee on the saucer and did not even notice. I had to use a napkin to clean it up.

It was good, lovely waiter, food average, there was an argument between owners

Decor was shabby, tables were too small, had to pay extra for sides and sauces. Ordered pepper sauce on my steak, got gravy out of a packet with no peppercorns, ordered green leaves, bot boiled broccoli.

Service and food were outstanding. Perfect place for lunch with old friends

Great food and service pleasant surroundings will be back soon

The staff were highly professional and knowledgeable of the wine list