Looks like something didn't work quite right. Please reload this page.
Restaurants
Melbourne
Carlton
Jimmy Watson's
Jimmy Watson's Reviews

Jimmy Watson's

Australian, Eat & Drink, Drinks

Dishes priced around$29

Photo of restaurant Jimmy Watson's in Carlton, Melbourne

Fast and free booking for:

Reviews of Jimmy Watson's (75)

Read what people think about Jimmy Watson's. All restaurant reviews are written by verified Quandoo diners. Learn more about Jimmy Watson's before you go by getting tips and ratings from other restaurant-goers. With real-life reviews, you can see what other diners loved about Jimmy Watson's and book a table with confidence!

5.0/6

75 reviews

5.0/6

75 reviews

Food:Outstanding
Atmosphere:Excellent
Service:Excellent
Value for money:Good value
Waiting time:Exceptionally Good
Noise levels:Very pleasant
627
536
44
36
21
11
Most recent
  • Most recent
  • Highest rated
  • Lowest rated
New"Excellent"
6/6
Gaynor B.17 hours ago · 1 review

Service and food were outstanding. Perfect place for lunch with old friends

New"Very good"
5/6
Lesley M.21 hours ago · 1 review

Great food and service pleasant surroundings will be back soon

New"Excellent"
6/6
David P.5 days ago · 1 review

The staff were highly professional and knowledgeable of the wine list

New"Average"
3/6
Kelly L.7 days ago · 1 review

Staff were great. Wine selection was good. The food was average. pizza was sloppy and undercooked. Arancini balls were dry. ‘Foccacia’bread was just white sliced bread served with packaged butter.

New"Excellent"
6/6
Darcy W.8 days ago · 1 review

Amazing food and table service! Pasta was incredible as was dessert.

New"Excellent"
6/6
Ruth H.11 days ago · 3 reviews

My friend and I enjoyed a leisurely lunch with great service. Cocktails made to order and wines to taste before ordering. The recommended fish dish was delicious. Thank you!

"Very good"
5/6
Sylvie M.18 days ago · 1 review

Both food and service was great. Very friendly and attentive.

"Good"
4/6
Guido L.a month ago · 3 reviews

A fabulous institution that has weathered the test of time very well. I’ve been a patron of Jimmy Watson’s for some 30 years and it’s still serving up great food, brilliant wines, a chilled atmosphere where you can actually have a conversation, and service focused staff who know their trade.

"Excellent"
6/6
Mette H.a month ago · 1 review

Amazing service - Superb food , Great vibes ❣️ thanks

"Very good"
5/6
jackie b.a month ago · 1 review

Good service and great food !!! We got to meet Jimmy Watson s son

"Excellent"
6/6
Brian T.a month ago · 1 review

As our table was very near the kitchen; while pondering over the menu on what to order, the chef came & to offer his suggestions. We took most of his advice. All food items really tasty. Special mention goes to my meal of mussels in white wine & chilli tomato base. Best I’ve had for many years. Just the right spice & chili factor. Have asked the waitress to pass on feedback. Calamari so fresh, the homemade bread, lamb rack etc

"Good"
4/6
Mary C.2 months ago · 1 review

Excellent shared vegetarian platter very good value for two. Tables a little too small for four people.

"Excellent"
6/6
Quandoo Diner3 months ago · 1 review

We think both the food and the service are great

"Very good"
5/6
Mark C.3 months ago · 1 review

Wonderful staff, great food and excellent wine. Plus much-loved companions. What more is there?

"Very good"
5/6
Ann B.4 months ago · 1 review

The head waiter is an absolute gem - kind and attentive.

"Very good"
5/6
Jim M.4 months ago · 1 review

There’s a healthy nostalgia about visiting Watsons. Always an enjoyable experience Bonus today - Allan Watson was there! Food good. Wine. Good. Atmosphere good.

"Average"
3/6
Jennifer W.4 months ago · 1 review

I like Jimmy's but this was a disappointing experience. My dish, which contained a minimal amount of poached salmon and some rocket, cost $30 and arrived without any dressing. I had to ask for this to be added. We arrived at 7pm and had to leave shortly after 8.30 because the staff were closing up. We were not offered dessert because the kitchen was closed. I can't believe that this is an appropriate way to run a restaurant.

"Very good"
5/6
Brian R.4 months ago · 1 review

Good food and excellent service. Pleasant dining atmosphere and restaurant set out.

"Very good"
5/6
Susan G.4 months ago · 1 review

Great food, wine, service and atmosphere. Very reasonably priced. Thanks

"Very good"
5/6
Genevieve B.5 months ago · 2 reviews

Table for 3. We ordered the charcuterie shared platter which was good but I’d have likes a bit more vegetable and less pate. Service was very good. Surrounding always lovely!

"Excellent"
6/6
Rose T.5 months ago · 1 review

The food was lovely and we enjoyed a very nice wine with our meal. Thanks to the friendly and efficient staff.

"Very good"
5/6
Eamonn C.5 months ago · 1 review

Great, as usual over the last 50 years i've been going to JW's.

"Very good"
5/6
Andrew R.6 months ago · 1 review

Great food and service. It was great to revisit this iconic establishment

"Excellent"
6/6
JOHN P.6 months ago · 1 review

Great food and professional service. I’ve never had a bad night out out Jimmy Watsons.

"Very good"
5/6
Warren M.6 months ago · 2 reviews

Jimmy Watson's has been an Institutional eating/drinking part of our lives for over 55 years. It remains authentic and very personal.

"Very good"
5/6
Quandoo Diner6 months ago · 1 review

Always a wonderful time. A great menu, of course amazing wine list and relaxed atmosphere. And always the most warm welcome from the charming Mr Watson and the staff. Coming home to friends.

"Excellent"
6/6
Jimmy K.6 months ago · 2 reviews

Great food. Great atmosphere. Great service. Will come back again.

"Very good"
5/6
Vicki F.7 months ago · 1 review

A quiet lunch with the son of and old friend (whom I've known since he was born and who is now 50 but haven't seen for a long while!) We had a familiar seat at a table in a niche near the window. Jimmy Watson's has been a part of my life since my university days in the 70's. So lovely always to reconnect.

"Excellent"
6/6
Dale M.7 months ago · 1 review

Great service and high quality food with a busy environment

"Good"
4/6
Tara O.8 months ago · 1 review

Had lunch with a couple of elderly friends. Sat in the courtyard and had a delightful afternoon. Good food, service and ambience.

"Very good"
5/6
Susan G.8 months ago · 1 review

Great food service & ambience fabulous always love going back now living Bayside I wish we had something like this in Brighton would be an absolute winner

"Very good"
5/6
Jo-Anne C.8 months ago · 1 review

The waitstaff were efficient and attentive. Lots of greenery and a good atmosphere in the courtyard.

"Very good"
5/6
Carolyn L.8 months ago · 3 reviews

Always reliable, always a great atmosphere, always enjoyable to return!

"Excellent"
6/6
Stephanie P.9 months ago · 1 review

Jimmy’s has great food, great cocktails and wine, great service, and so much character. It feels like a family restaurant where the greeting is warm and pride is justified. No wonder this place has lasted all these years. I will be going back.

"Very good"
5/6
Ruta B.9 months ago · 1 review

A warm welcome, cosy and hospitable ambience and a palpable feeing of its legendary history of fine wine and great food; this is what our recent lunch at Jimmy Watson's delivered. A truly precious, culinary institution.

"Very good"
5/6
Greg P.10 months ago · 1 review

I enjoy the unpretentious ambience and good value food and wine. A great place for our regular old-school catch-up.

"Very good"
5/6
Nicky W.10 months ago · 1 review

Grand Final day was a great time to go to Lygon Street Food and staff were amazing

"Very good"
5/6
Genevieve B.10 months ago · 2 reviews

Great food! Lovely wine! We left early because the table next to us with 6 people was so loud. We couldn’t hear each other speak.

"Not good "
2/6
Wendy W.10 months ago · 1 review

Delicious main courses but no desert available. Chef had gone home by 9.30. Unheard of! Had to go elsewhere for an ice cream.

"Excellent"
6/6
Anthea A.10 months ago · 1 review

Jamie was amazing looking after us and the food was perfect

"Very good"
5/6
Andrew G.10 months ago · 1 review

A good meal in a pleasant environment. Would go again.

"Average"
3/6
Assunta M.10 months ago · 1 review

Arancini and duck were very dry and no flavour. Took us 10 years to go back since our first visit. Might be another 10 years before we go again

"Excellent"
6/6
Jennifer L.a year ago · 1 review

Amazing food! Barramundi with prawn and crab bisque and semolina cake with pistachio icecream were superb. Still the same atmosphere - quintessential Melbourne.

"Excellent"
6/6
Annette B.a year ago · 1 review

Great food, extensive wine list would certainly return n ct time we are in Melbourne

"Average"
3/6
Paul A.a year ago · 1 review

It was pretty empty and missing a bit of atmosphere that could have been achieved with lower lights etc.

"Excellent"
6/6
Vicky S.a year ago · 1 review

From the time we walked in till the time we walked out I cannot fault it. Nike was amazing, waited on us in a very friendly and profesional manner. My dish was want I was expecting, 10 /10, wine was excellent and desert just as good. Definitely we return to Jimmy Watson’s.

"Average"
3/6
Dana M.a year ago · 1 review

We were a little squished at our table and with the sun streaming in those facing the window needed to wear sunglasses. The joy of lunchtime bookings. The bentwood chairs are a beautiful vintage touch but perhaps a cushion would make them at least a little bit comfortable

"Excellent"
6/6
Terence M.a year ago · 4 reviews

As always, super food and service. The Jimmy Watson Barossa Shiraz is excellent.

"Average"
3/6
Karen G.a year ago · 1 review

Have always enjoyed food at Jimmy Watsons but was disappointed today with the dishes. Service is always very good.

"Excellent"
6/6
Charlie R.a year ago · 1 review

Lovely service, friendly vibe. Food was tasty. Good place to have a quiet wine with a loved one, good meal, and walk up and down Lygon afterwards.

Earn cashback as you dine

Create a Quandoo account and earn $4.50 cashback.

Book a table and earn $6.75 cashback.

Leave a review and earn $2.25 cashback.