Looks like something didn't work quite right. Please reload this page.
Restaurants
Melbourne
Mentone
Just Italy - Mentone
Just Italy - Mentone Reviews

Just Italy - Mentone

Photo of restaurant Just Italy - Mentone in Mentone, Melbourne
Just Italy - Mentone is not bookable via Quandoo yet. To make a reservation, contact the restaurant using the details below. Checkout the opening hours first and bear in mind that if you reserve ahead, you won't have to wait in line.

Reviews of Just Italy - Mentone (321)

Read what people think about Just Italy - Mentone. All restaurant reviews are written by verified Quandoo diners. Learn more about Just Italy - Mentone before you go by getting tips and ratings from other restaurant-goers. With real-life reviews, you can see what other diners loved about Just Italy - Mentone and book a table with confidence!

5.1/6

321 reviews

5.1/6

321 reviews

Food:Outstanding
Atmosphere:Excellent
Service:Excellent
Value for money:Great value
Waiting time:Exceptionally Good
Noise levels:Pleasant
6167
585
433
324
25
17
Most recent
  • Most recent
  • Highest rated
  • Lowest rated
"Not good "
2/6
Bec H.4 years ago · 1 review

Food was okay but service was so slow and terrible. Took 30 minutes before we could order after grabbing the waiters multiple times and kept being told “yes ok 1 minute”. The wait for food was an hour and when it did come out there was then another 20 minute wait between mine and my partners meal. I was finished before he had even got his. Not a single smile from any of the staff there and basic service skills were seriously lacking.

"Good"
4/6
Melissa L.4 years ago · 1 review

Nice food, lovely staff. However extremely short staffed, leading to extremely slow service.

"Excellent"
6/6
Louise H.4 years ago · 1 review

Delicious food. Friendly service. Great vibe. Perfect addition to Mentone.

"Excellent"
6/6
Penni B.4 years ago · 1 review

Great venue! Great food. Definitely see you again! 😊 thank you!

"Excellent"
6/6
Carol L.4 years ago · 2 reviews

Great authentic Italian food with fantastic service at a very reasonable price. Loved it and will definitely return.

"Excellent"
6/6
Angie R.4 years ago · 1 review

Great atmosphere! The pizzas are the best around, thin crust, freshest ingredients, awesome!

"Awful"
1/6
Rebecca L.4 years ago · 1 review

Awful food and service. I wouldn't return here it was not an enjoyable evening.

"Not good "
2/6
Zoe D.4 years ago · 1 review

Food was nice staff were rude unfortunately! Disappointing for a new business. Long wait time, no smiles

"Good"
4/6
Jan M.4 years ago · 1 review

Wrong sauce on pasta, dessert arrived with no cutlery and ice cream rather than cream as listed on the menu. No staff to greet or direct us on arrival. Generally staff could have been friendlier but a great space and location. Booked ahead so no waiting time except to be directed to our table.

"Very good"
5/6
Debra H.4 years ago · 1 review

This place has only been opened a short time but I found the upstairs area very nice. Bit of glare as the sun was setting, maybe be a blind or two on the window for the short time. Food was nice, service good considering the place was packed. I will be returning.

"Average"
3/6
Anita W.4 years ago · 2 reviews

Nice looking place but food/drink options bit lacking in variety & substance

"Very good"
5/6
Philippa D.4 years ago · 1 review

Nice casual restaurant- great space, good value food and quick, friendly service

"Good"
4/6
Stuart C.4 years ago · 1 review

Great atmosphere. Food was a little cold but the tastes amazing. Most likely just new restaurant jitters.

"Excellent"
6/6
John B.4 years ago · 1 review

great spot! good honest iti food with very friendly service

"Average"
3/6
Mark N.4 years ago · 2 reviews

Spinach and ricotta agnoletti was bland and garlic bread a bit burnt. Overall disappointed after the great reviews.

"Excellent"
6/6
Theresa V.4 years ago · 1 review

Great atmosphere ! Good sized food portions. Pastas and pizzas delicious. Young waiter who served our table was very attentive to our needs. An enjoyable dining experience. Thank you Just Italy.

"Excellent"
6/6
Anthony S.4 years ago · 1 review

Great venue, great food and service. All round great experience

"Good"
4/6
Betty N.4 years ago · 1 review

Was not handed a bill but told to pay at counter. Total amount was quoted and had to request bill. New restaurant so perhaps things will improve as was extra busy with locals keen to try a new eatery.

"Excellent"
6/6
Maria M.4 years ago · 1 review

This is my 3rd visit since the opening night. Just love the place. Staff and food is beautiful. Real authentic Italian food.❤️

"Excellent"
6/6
Claire P.4 years ago · 1 review

Amazing new local spot. Food was delicious!! Great for the area!

"Very good"
5/6
Tony S.4 years ago · 1 review

Really good fòod, very pleasant staff. See you there soon.

"Excellent"
6/6
Alex D.4 years ago · 1 review

Great food and atmosphere! Mentone needed it a good Italian place 👍🍷🍝🍕🙌 10/10.

"Good"
4/6
Mary R.4 years ago · 1 review

We understand that the restaurant has only been open for a week, so lots of teething problems. When we arrived, we were advised that we had the table for one hour to one and a half hours, this was OK, as we had not intended to stay long anyway, but we waited 20 minutes for drinks and one of the main meals did not arrive with the others. Lots of staff learning the ropes - the waitresses we had were lovely and trying really hard to do everything correctly. Very noisy and lots of flies inside, so maybe a fly zapper. Will give it another try down the track, when things maybe settle a little. Thank you.

"Excellent"
6/6
Dawn W.4 years ago · 2 reviews

Food was Just Fabulous at Just Italy! We had the degustation and we were not disappointed with any of the dishes served. We will definitely be back.

"Good"
4/6
carli h.4 years ago · 1 review

I had the Seafood Ravioli. It was bland and presentation could have came out with a bit of green garnish on top to make it look nice. A little disappointed but loved how they have designed and furnished the restaurant and the atmosphere was relaxed and fun. I will be back.

"Very good"
5/6
Peter T.4 years ago · 1 review

Great spot for great pizza, we definitely will go again

"Very good"
5/6
Stephen B.4 years ago · 1 review

Only new and the restaurant was busy. Needed to chase the waiter to get service. Not too bad and should improve over time. Good pizza and good price. We will be back

"Excellent"
6/6
Luisa S.4 years ago · 1 review

Fantastic addition to Mentone! Delicious food, great atmosphere and beautiful location! A real winner!

"Excellent"
6/6
Rebecca W.4 years ago · 1 review

Seriously the best olive ascolane outside of Ascoli Piceno. My favorite place for all things Italian.

"Excellent"
6/6
Lynda R.4 years ago · 1 review

Great to see an authentic Italian restaurant in Mentone. This place will do very well

"Excellent"
6/6
Frank D.4 years ago · 1 review

Loved it felt like we were back in Italy great to finally have a lovely place to eat out in Mentone.

"Excellent"
6/6
Silvana P.4 years ago · 1 review

Authentic Italian food experience. We tried meatballs. arancini, pizzas, pastas and the melanzane parmigiano- all delicious and left us wanting to return to try more items on the menu. Generous portions. Friendly service. Amazing coffee. Buzzing atmosphere. Do yourself a favour and head on down.

"Average"
3/6
Helen W.4 years ago · 1 review

Food was great. Service very slow. Some of the meals came out much later than others at our table, not together. Staff friendly but unsure and inexperienced

"Excellent"
6/6
Narelle C.4 years ago · 2 reviews

Excellent food, service and atmosphere. This was the opening weekend very impressed. If you go try the sweet potato gnocchi with cream sauce and peas mmm yum.

"Very good"
5/6
Tim L.4 years ago · 1 review

The service and the warmth from the staff was spot on. You could tell they were making everyone welcome. The pizza was brilliant. The food wasn’t perfect (yet) but in the coming weeks they will have this place humming. You can see very clearly how good this place will be. All meals needed more sauce. Well done guys on your 3rd night. It’s an incredible achievement by the owners to present a beautiful establishment like this one. Stunning renovation of one of Mentone’s iconic sites. Can’t wait for the rooftop to open. Will be back in a few weeks when the small issues are sorted.

"Excellent"
6/6
Nando D.4 years ago · 1 review

Great, friendly service in a wonderful atmosphere. The food was amazing and we can’t wait to return.

"Excellent"
6/6
Michelle P.4 years ago · 2 reviews

Beautiful Italian Food. Great owners. So happy to have a local restaurant of this quality. We will definitely return.

"Good"
4/6
Steve M.4 years ago · 1 review

Tables were too close upstairs with people squeezing past all through the sitting. Anchovies and burrata very nice entrees, veal snitzel was tender however the salad with it was only lettuce with a tiny bit of red onion. The fettuccine carbonara was quite bland. For the desserts the cannolis very tasty and crisp, whilst the tiramisu was very good. We did like the look of the pizzas being delivered to other tables so will try them when we visit next time. The service was slow however this was understandable for second night open.

"Excellent"
6/6
Marie G.4 years ago · 1 review

Food was delicious and tasty. It was day 2 so so understand there is some timing issues. All good will be back.

"Excellent"
6/6
Alison W.4 years ago · 1 review

Amazing food and service. A bit slow but it was the opening night. Just what the area needs- as locals we are excited to have such a great place opening with such enthusiastic staff! Can’t wait to come back!

...